Name: Parallel Sessions 7D: Service or Scientific Contribution? Promoting and Recognizing Best Review Practices
Start: 2025-07-23T10:30:00-0700
End: 2025-07-23T11:45:00-0700

Wednesday July 23, 2025 10:30am - 11:45am PDT

Taper Hall (THH) 210

Panel: Service or Scientific Contribution? Promoting and Recognizing Best Review Practices
Chair: Katya Scheinberg and Frank E. Curtis
Panelists: Jerome Bolte, Benjamin Grimmer, Tim Hoheisel, Giacomo Nanicini, Clement Royer

Abstract: This panel is another session in a series of similar events, previously held at SIOPT in 2023 and at ISMP 2024. A short summary of past events and their conclusions will be made available prior to this panel.

In this panel the panelists are reviewers and associate editors with significant experience. We will discuss the merits of journal reviews, try to identify key components that make up good reviews, discuss the roles of editors and reviewers and how their efforts should be recognized by the community. We will welcome questions and comments from the audience.

Speakers

Katya Scheinberg

Professor, Georgia Institute of Technology

Name:Katya Scheinberg Title: Coca-Cola Foundation Chair and ProfessorAffiliation: H. Milton Stewart School of Industrial and Systems Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GABio:Katya Scheinberg is a Coca-Cola Foundation Chair and Professor in the H. Milton Stewart... Read More →

Frank E. Curtis

Professor, Lehigh University

Name: Frank E. Curtis, Ph.D.Title: ProfessorAffiliation: Lehigh UniversityBio: Please see my website.Fun Fact: My wife and I have been together for 20 years and she's never seen me without a beard.

Benjamin Grimmer

Name: Dr. Slothington "Slow Convergence" McNapface Title: Distinguished Professor of Continuous Optimization & Energy Minimization Affiliation: The Lush Canopy Institute of Sluggish Algorithms Bio: Dr. Slothington McNapface is a leading expert in continuous optimization, specializing... Read More →

Clément Royer

Associate professor, Université Paris Dauphine-PSL

Clément W. Royer is an associate professor of computer science at Université Paris Dauphine-PSL. Clément received his Ph.D. from the University of Toulouse, France, and was then a postdoctoral research associate at the Wisconsin Institute of Discovery, University of Wisconsin-Madison... Read More →

Jérôme Bolte

Jérôme Bolte is a Full Professor at the Toulouse School of Economics and holds a Chair in Artificial Intelligence at the Artificial Intelligence Institute of Toulouse (ANITI). He studied pure and applied mathematics before completing a degree in mathematics and then a doctorate... Read More →

Tim Hoheisel

Tim Hoheisel received his doctorate of mathematics from Julius-Maximilians University (Würzburg) under the supervision of Christian Kanzow in 2009. He was a postdoctoral researcher there until 2016. During this time, he was a visiting professor at Heinrich-Heine University (Düsseldorf... Read More →

Giacomo Nannicini

Wednesday July 23, 2025 10:30am - 11:45am PDT
Taper Hall (THH) 210 3501 Trousdale Pkwy, 210, Los Angeles, CA 90089

Parallel Session

ICCOPT2025USC